Comments and Feedback

I think it's a great idea. My understanding of lending to women in third world countries is that at this point they have a very low default rate compared to men, or their counterparts in places like the United States, and they have been very successful in their ventures. I think it is s good idea and, if it remains with a good deal of transparency, a better idea.
POSTED Tue, Aug 21, 2007 9:42 PM PDT
Evidence overwhelming supports the notion that if you educate women, give them the tools and empower them to be successful, a stronger nation you will build. Thank you Matt, Jessica and Premal for making the WORLD a better place!
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:09 PM PDT
I think this idea will eventually die as borrowers will find ways to cheat the lenders and lenders will stop lending. Unless there is a sure way to monitor these loans and make sure that borrower is using it for the purpose that was stated in the application and then finally repay it. Since lending is being extended all over the world and there is not an easy way to monitor, I think most of the lenders will find that their money is actually not serving the purpose and being lost in the nature of how humans behave.
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:16 PM PDT
The article conveniently ignores the commission that Kiva charges on the loans that originate through its website. While the commission is significantly less than that charged by loan sharks, it is much more than what a traditional financial institute would charge. And lets not forget that those loan sharks and the traditional institutions are assuming all the risk of defaults. But kiva? Its making money without taking any risk, while putting a cloak of goodwill and earning grants from Yahoo!, Paypal and I-dont-know-how-many-more companies
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:22 PM PDT
When did this article become a gender issue? Did I miss something in the article that says the lending and subsequent excellent default rate applies only to women? My experience is that people who have nothing and are given something )such as an interest free loan) tend to be very gratetful and thus more responsible with what they have been given - regardless of their gender
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:34 PM PDT
Evidence overwhelming supports the notion that if you educate ANYONE, give them the tools and empower them to be successful, a stronger nation you will build.
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:36 PM PDT
This is great, but what about people right here in the US that work hard and still can't get a loan? Shouldn't charity BEGIN here?
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:37 PM PDT
What's my incentive, other than perhaps goodwill, to invest in this program? Is there a return on my investment, albeit a small one?
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:45 PM PDT
while there may be people who will cheat the system, that is true of any aide, be it International Red Cross/Red Crescent or the PeaceCorps or the MacArthur Foundation, but this is different because if people are cheating, or not making the most of their loan, they'll have less to show, and people will be less willing to invest in them. And though they may charge a higher rate than the larger institutions, they are also willing to work with a much smaller amount of money, much more people, and with people who are far more marginalized. That cost is the passed on to the client...it's how a business works.
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:46 PM PDT
Sounds like you are going to have huge credit risk. Seen the sub-prime markets lately; this looks even worse in the long run. Great idea to "help the world", but I would estimate your firm will be bankrupt in less than 4 years. Prove me wrong!
POSTED Wed, Aug 22, 2007 12:47 PM PDT
1 - 10 of 1132 First | Previous | Next | Last
You must sign in to leave a comment

People of the Web

The $10 Million Giveaway?

Move over Sally Struthers. Three young entrepreneurs found an easier way to raise millions for struggling businesses almost anywhere in the world. But don’t call it a handout -- it’s a loan. And, it’s funded by everyday people, like you, $25 at a time.

By KEVIN SITES, TUE AUG 21, 5:27 PM PDT

In their office in San Francisco's Mission District, Matt and Jessica Flannery and Premal Shah work with the fervor and techno savvy of an Internet startup aiming for an IPO. But they aren't chasing the cash for themselves.

Matt and Jessica Flannery and Premal Shah bring a youthful vibe to the world of microfinance.

They're doing it for Esther Egbulu in Nigeria, a mother of six who wants an $800 loan to stock her shop with frozen chickens and turkey, or 31-year-old Choeun Sonin, who's requesting $1,000 to purchase a motorcycle taxi — just two of 15,000 entrepreneurs from 36 countries that their company, Kiva, has already helped.

Kiva, which means "unity" in Swahili, is a lending organization with a twist: Anyone with a bit of money and an Internet connection can step forward as a microlender to assist struggling third-world entrepreneurs get out of poverty.

After logging in, you can scroll through profiles of entrepreneurs, descriptions of their businesses, and the loan amounts they're requesting. Once you've decided who you want to lend to, you choose how much to lend, starting at as little as $25. (Individual lenders can fund an entire loan, but most of Kiva's loans are funded by multiple lenders.)

Funds are distributed to entrepreneurs through local non-profit microfinance partners in specific countries.

In Nigeria, Esther Egbulu wants an $800 loan to stock her shop with frozen chickens.

The key is that the company is based on loans, not donations. "You're fundamentally connecting with someone else in a way that's based on mutual dignity, not this supplicant-benefactor relationship that you often see in philanthropy," says Premal.

There are some differences from traditional lending.  Kiva loans require no collateral and they are zero interest. PayPal (Premal's former employer) processes the transactions without any fees.

Premal says the average loan request is about $650 and the average lender usually funds three different entrepreneurs at $25 each. Eighty percent of the lenders come from the U.S., 10% from Canada, and the remainder from the rest of the world.

Kiva says entrepreneurs pay back their loans an incredible 99% of the time — a default rate unheard of at traditional financial institutions. (The Kiva team expects the default rate to increase to 5% as more borrowers complete the loan cycle.)  And according to Premal, most lenders reinvest their money in other entrepreneurs after a loan is paid back.

Kiva's operational costs are covered by donations from lenders. The company does not take a commission from the loans facilitated on the site.

Matt and Jessica Flannery created Kiva after discovering different career goals in a pre-marriage counseling course.

The way Kiva was founded is almost as interesting as what it's accomplishing. When Matt and Jessica attended a pre-marriage counseling session, they discovered their career goals could keep them apart. Jessica wanted to go to Africa to study microfinance; Matt was headed to Silicon Valley.

"We sort of just thought, ‘Well, we're supposed to be together.  This will work itself out,'" Jessica recalls.

Things did work out, but in a way they hadn't first imagined. Shortly after they were married, Matt went to work for TiVo and Jessica went to Africa to work with a microfinance organization.  

After visiting Jessica in Africa, Matt got the idea that perhaps what she was doing, microfinance, and what he was doing, high tech, could be combined — using the Internet to connect lenders and entrepreneurs.

They tested the concept on friends and family, spamming their wedding list and raising more than $3,000 for a handful of small businesses in Uganda.

Now Kiva has loans totaling $10 million.

Matt, Jessica and Premal credit their corresponding strengths for Kiva's success so far: Matt's technological know-how, Premal's salesmanship and Jessica's heart.

Kiva's president Premal Shah says corruption is a reality and he hopes transparency on Kiva's site will boost lenders confidence in microfinance.

Kiva faces new challenges as its base of lenders and entrepreneurs expands.

Ensuring that money actually funds business is one problem. For instance, a borrower in Cambodia used a loan to fund a family wedding. But a Kiva volunteer monitoring loans in Cambodia discovered what happened then blogged about it — on Kiva's own website.

"We know that corruption exists," says Premal. "We are adamant about exposing it on our website." Transparency, he says, is the organization's goal.

In the grand scheme of things, $10 million in loans might seem like a small dent in world poverty, but Kiva's founders are thinking big.

"In year five we're looking at anywhere between $150 million to $280 million," says Premal — potentially enough to move the GDP of an entire nation at some point.

For now, it's enough to change the lives of 15,000 struggling entrepreneurs — and perhaps those making the loans, as well.

Note: Yahoo! for Good provides Kiva with a quarterly search marketing grant.  

 

Producer: Erin Green
Video Editor: Steve Neilson
 

Tools

Rate This Story

Rate this Story:

Average Not Rated

0.0 stars

Do you run a Web site you think we should feature? Do you know of a great story about the Web you think we should follow up on? Let us know.

Featured Video

More People of the Web

Up Down